Hi guys,
I’m using a Dspline to flow a fluid around a bottle but I’m getting a rounded (cylindrical) shape as result.
I think is the drag daemon that is rounding the fluid, with a thinner start and end of the stream, and I’d like to get a more flat stream.
I’m using DSpline, Drag and a noise daemon (quiet low value on the noise)
Is there a workaround to maintain the fluid more planner during the dspline flow?
Thanks is advance
Dspline to get a ribbon
- ChristianZ
- Posts: 3427
- Joined: Sat Sep 09, 2006 11:37 am
- Location: CH
- Contact:
Re: Dspline to get a ribbon
Hi
a more ribbon-like shape could be obtained by using a linear emitter at the start of the Dspline and a relatively high "vortex strength". However, it is always a delicate balance between the vortex strength (which produces the cork-screw motion of the ribbon) and the "radial strength" (which moves the fluid forward along the spline). The perfect ribbon would be made by a linear emitter with low internal and low external pressure removing fluid properties, without drag or surface tension. But at the end of the day it is no longer a fluid simulation and you could be better off with a cloth simulation or other standard particle systems without fluid physics.
a more ribbon-like shape could be obtained by using a linear emitter at the start of the Dspline and a relatively high "vortex strength". However, it is always a delicate balance between the vortex strength (which produces the cork-screw motion of the ribbon) and the "radial strength" (which moves the fluid forward along the spline). The perfect ribbon would be made by a linear emitter with low internal and low external pressure removing fluid properties, without drag or surface tension. But at the end of the day it is no longer a fluid simulation and you could be better off with a cloth simulation or other standard particle systems without fluid physics.
RF10 standard + RFC4D
-
- Posts: 50
- Joined: Thu Jan 18, 2018 11:16 am
Re: Dspline to get a ribbon
Hi, thank you for your answer.
yours is a clever approach, but I still can't avoid the fact that the Dspline radial strength is gonna transform the linear particles emission in a cylindrical fluid right away as it gets influenced by the radial or vortex (or both).
The get a better approach of the effect, if I use a spline emitter and the spline used is a helix and I set the mode of the emitter to "Axis", I manage to get a fluid that is not rounded but flat (and this is what If like to achieve as fluid shape) and it doesn't have the first part of it (first particles) like compressed by the spline. Unfortunately using this method I can make the particles travel across the helix, as they are created at the same time all across it.
Basically, I want to avoid the particles to be flatten as the cross the fist Dspline circle...
I have attached a image of the spline emitter.
Thank you.
yours is a clever approach, but I still can't avoid the fact that the Dspline radial strength is gonna transform the linear particles emission in a cylindrical fluid right away as it gets influenced by the radial or vortex (or both).
The get a better approach of the effect, if I use a spline emitter and the spline used is a helix and I set the mode of the emitter to "Axis", I manage to get a fluid that is not rounded but flat (and this is what If like to achieve as fluid shape) and it doesn't have the first part of it (first particles) like compressed by the spline. Unfortunately using this method I can make the particles travel across the helix, as they are created at the same time all across it.
Basically, I want to avoid the particles to be flatten as the cross the fist Dspline circle...
I have attached a image of the spline emitter.
Thank you.
- ChristianZ
- Posts: 3427
- Joined: Sat Sep 09, 2006 11:37 am
- Location: CH
- Contact:
Re: Dspline to get a ribbon
Hi
yes, I see the problem... the beginning of the Dspline almost always acts like a "lens" that attracts the particles and pulls them together.
An alternative approach could be to move the linear emitter along a spline such that the emitter leaves the ribbon behind, without Dspline.
yes, I see the problem... the beginning of the Dspline almost always acts like a "lens" that attracts the particles and pulls them together.
An alternative approach could be to move the linear emitter along a spline such that the emitter leaves the ribbon behind, without Dspline.
RF10 standard + RFC4D
-
- Posts: 50
- Joined: Thu Jan 18, 2018 11:16 am
Re: Dspline to get a ribbon
Hi,
thanks for your answer, but now I can see how I will maintain the particles then attached to the spline, without flying away, as the emitter travels along the spline.
Do you think (I haven’t try yet) the “Spline Emitter” would do the job?
I think I saw in one of those LearnWaterDesign workshops the case study of Coca Cola with similar results.
Cheers,
thanks for your answer, but now I can see how I will maintain the particles then attached to the spline, without flying away, as the emitter travels along the spline.
Do you think (I haven’t try yet) the “Spline Emitter” would do the job?
I think I saw in one of those LearnWaterDesign workshops the case study of Coca Cola with similar results.
Cheers,
Re: Dspline to get a ribbon
You can also try that freebie: http://waterline.tv/downloads_03.html. Just look for the "Fluid Ribbons" chapter 
This project requires a script that's listed in the magazine as well. This script is responsible for the emitter's orientation along a spline/animation curve. If you don't want to use a script you can also animate the emitter by hand. In any case, the description shows you how to calm down your particles and make them stay in the air.

This project requires a script that's listed in the magazine as well. This script is responsible for the emitter's orientation along a spline/animation curve. If you don't want to use a script you can also animate the emitter by hand. In any case, the description shows you how to calm down your particles and make them stay in the air.
-
- Posts: 50
- Joined: Thu Jan 18, 2018 11:16 am
Re: Dspline to get a ribbon
Brilliant!
Thank you very much
Thank you very much
- ChristianZ
- Posts: 3427
- Joined: Sat Sep 09, 2006 11:37 am
- Location: CH
- Contact:
Re: Dspline to get a ribbon
Thanks Thomas!
How could I forget it..always check the waterline pdfs and the blog for in-depth RealFlow knowledge <thumbs up>
How could I forget it..always check the waterline pdfs and the blog for in-depth RealFlow knowledge <thumbs up>
RF10 standard + RFC4D
Re: Dspline to get a ribbon
ChristianZ wrote:How could I forget it..always check the waterline pdfs and the blog for in-depth RealFlow knowledge

-
- Posts: 50
- Joined: Thu Jan 18, 2018 11:16 am
Re: Dspline to get a ribbon
I have been simulating with the paint ribbons script quiet a lot today and I get what I was looking for, but it will look more realistic if I can get some particles not to be so attached to the main flow...
I tried adding noise falled-off daemons along the spline to get some trendils (I think it will look more realistic) but the drag daemon stick the particles so much that the particles can´t escape its force...
any idea will be helpful.
I could add a screenshot of my mainstream tomorrow if you need to see exactly how it looks.
Thank you anyway... I don´t think I could have get any better approach anyhow.
Cheers
I tried adding noise falled-off daemons along the spline to get some trendils (I think it will look more realistic) but the drag daemon stick the particles so much that the particles can´t escape its force...
any idea will be helpful.
I could add a screenshot of my mainstream tomorrow if you need to see exactly how it looks.
Thank you anyway... I don´t think I could have get any better approach anyhow.
Cheers
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests